Beyond the Script: The Humor, Heart, and Humanity of Healthcare Simulation
Compiled and edited by Javi Cabrera
Each year, Healthcare Simulation Week recognizes the people and innovations that prepare healthcare professionals for the complexities of patient care. From high-fidelity manikins to carefully designed clinical scenarios, simulation offers learners a space to practice, make mistakes, and grow. Yet, among its many moving parts, one essential element cannot be programmed or replicated by technology alone: human connection.
Standardized Patients (SPs), also known as Simulated Participants, are trained to portray patients, family members, and other roles in healthcare education. On paper, their responsibilities may seem straightforward: learn a case, portray a character, and provide feedback. In reality, the work demands preparation, emotional intelligence, and the ability to respond authentically to another person.
To celebrate Healthcare Simulation Week, the Association of SP Educators (ASPE) invited SPs to share their experiences through SP Stories: In Their Own Words. Their responses reveal the humor, heart, and unexpected moments behind the role.
Expect the Unexpected
We began by asking SPs to share a funny or surprising moment during simulation. And as anyone familiar with simulation knows, sometimes the most memorable moments are the ones nobody planned.
For Lynn Eldredge of Nevada, even a routine physical examination can deliver a surprise: "I have very strong knee reflexes & it can startle a first-year student."
Diane Senffner of Kentucky recalled a student delivering the news of a heart attack with an enormous smile, cheerfully wishing her patient a wonderful day before realizing what she'd said. An accidental expletive followed, and everyone laughed.
But not every surprise comes with a punchline.
During a routine simulation examination, a student noticed an abnormality in Mark Whitlock's prostate. After following up with his physician, Mark from Illinois, was diagnosed with stage 2 cancer.
"Being an SP literally saved my life."
Nearly five years later, following treatment, Mark continues working as an SP. His experience is an extraordinary reminder that even simulated encounters involve real people.
Keeping the Role Alive
With some SPs portraying the same patient more than ten times a day, we wondered: how do they keep each encounter fresh?
For Judith Sachs of Pennsylvania, "The new student makes the role fresh!"
That unpredictability is precisely what makes active listening so essential. Each learner approaches the patient differently, and even a familiar script can lead somewhere unexpected.
Diane approaches this through an acting technique called the moment before, imagining what her character is experiencing just before the learner enters. When a student once asked how SPs manage to cry on cue, she replied:
"You just told me I have cancer. It's real and you made it feel real."
The emotion wasn't simply performed; it emerged from listening and responding to the circumstances of the encounter.
The Moments That Matter
Beyond the unexpected and the theatrical, we asked SPs about the moments that reminded them why their work matters.
Judith recalled portraying a mother whose daughter had been in a car accident and was brain dead. After delivering the devastating news, the medical student, nearly in tears, admitted she didn't believe she could handle such a conversation.
Judith's response? "You just did."
Sometimes, the impact of an encounter takes years to reveal itself. Linda Young of California remembered a nervous first-year student whose hands shook during an examination. Years later, she encountered that same learner again, now serving as a preceptor.
"I felt like a proud MaMa."
Whether offering reassurance in a difficult moment or witnessing a learner's growth, SPs help build confidence that extends beyond the simulation room.
More Than Just Acting
So, what do SPs wish more people understood about their work?
"Listening skills! Improvisation! Working with each learner individually rather than simply memorizing a case," Judith emphasized.
Dulse VanSolo of Illinois similarly described the challenge of improvising naturally while remaining faithful to a simulation's educational goals. After all, learners don't follow scripts, even when SPs do.
That balance becomes especially important during feedback. Diane recalled a student who, attempting to be inclusive, asked her patient character, "How much are you smoking?" The character had quit two years earlier. Rather than simply correcting the student, Diane explored how the question unintentionally assumed continued tobacco use.
It was a small exchange with a meaningful lesson: how we ask can matter just as much as what we ask.
Mira Soni of Doha, Qatar, takes that idea a step further, emphasizing the importance of listening beyond spoken words. For her, SP work requires paying attention to "what the student may not be saying," recognizing that meaningful communication involves more than the words exchanged.
These stories remind us that SPs do more than portray patients. They listen, adapt, and help learners recognize the human impact of their words and actions.
While a script may tell an SP what to say, it is the person behind the role who makes the encounter feel real.
With gratitude to our SP Voices contributors: Judith Sachs, Robert Overall, Linda Young, Dulse VanSolo, Patricia Wilson Martin, Diane Senffner, Lynn Eldredge, Mark Whitlock, and Mira Soni.
